Friday, August 07, 2009

Convenient Destruction

Yesterday, the Knox County Election Commission defeated the so-called "convenience voting" in a 3-2 vote. The result is a classic example of just why the change in composition of Tennessee's county election commissions from Democratic dominance to Republican control is so important-especially in East Tennessee:

The pilot project, which would have replaced the city's 52 precinct polls with 10 centrally located voting centers open during a 20-day window, needed a supermajority of four votes among the five appointed election commissioners. The panel's three Republican members voted against the proposal, voicing their skepticism of whether the plan would actually making the voting process more convenient for citizens.

"Right now, we have convenience voting," said Commissioner Paul Crilly, a Republican, noting the two-week early voting periods that already precede election days.

"And we have other means - absentee ballots and so forth. I'm not comfortable with changing our system for the convenience of the county."

There is a reason that Crilly and the other Republican Election Commissioners are so concerned about this new "convenience" and its elimination of the precinct-in Knox County, as in most East Tennessee counties, the Republican party is organized by precinct. Each precinct has a precinct Chairman and a number of precinct delegates who can be convened to district conventions if necessary. More importantly, these precinct organizations are what help with Republican get-out-the-vote efforts all over East Tennessee. The Knox County Republican Party's governing apparatus has been in some disarray for a couple of years at least, but the precinct structure is still very much in place, along with neighborhood Republican clubs.

Similarly, the precinct structure is very much in place in Jefferson County, and will likely be re-enforced with a Republican-led Election Commission. Why would certain people want to take this "pilot program" to other East Tennessee counties, and then Statewide? Because Democrats know that in East Tennessee, Republican dominance filters down to the precinct level, and they can't beat Republicans at the polls, so they must destroy the party from within.

Destroy the precinct, and you can destroy the Republican Party in East Tennessee. Perhaps the politically naive can't see that would be the ultimate end of such a voting scheme, but neither the Democrats who came up with the idea nor the veteran Republicans on the Election Commission are that naive. Republicans are not going to sign off on their own partisan death warrant.

Labels: , , , ,


At Friday, August 07, 2009 9:15:00 AM, Blogger Steve Mule said...

You are really being an idiot. Convenience Voting would not have done away with the precinct system. It would have been just like Early Voting only ten days longer and without an election day cluster screw.
The precincts would have remained in place as a geographical area just as county commission districts would remain in place.
And, by the way, Democrats use precincts too, for the same reasons Republicans do.


At Friday, August 07, 2009 7:29:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Have to agree with you Mule - Oats is an idiot. Face it, the real reason that Repubs hate convenience voting is that it increases turnout. When turnout increases, Repubs lose elections - it's as simple as that.

At Sunday, August 09, 2009 6:04:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...


At Sunday, August 09, 2009 9:45:00 PM, Blogger joe lance said...

I have been reading David Oatney for a long time, and he is no idiot. I happen to disagree with him on this, and have just published my thoughts on my own blog, but there are plenty of ways to disagree without calling someone names.

David uses facts in his rationale, and though I disagree with his conclusion, I appreciate the effort and thoughtfulness that led to it.


Post a Comment

<< Home

Locations of visitors to this page
Profile Visitor Map - Click to view visits
Create your own visitor map